Seven parliamentary questions about the Ministry of Defence’s rules. One blanket refusal because a constituent is taking it to court. Apparently, my litigation now explains why Parliament cannot be told how the Department works.I wanted to know how the Ministry of Defence works.
An ambitious project, admittedly.
In previous articles, I have described the Department’s refusal to engage substantively with my complaints, including matters which I maintain fall outside my existing court proceedings.
Eventually, my MP’s office offered another route: formulate general questions and put them to the Ministry through Parliament.
So I designed them carefully.
They would ask about policies, procedures, responsibilities and safeguards. They would not ask a minister to decide my claims, assess my evidence or announce that Janina White was right.
My litigation already supplies considerable material for analysis. The Department’s lawyers have proved remarkably productive contributors.
This exercise had a public purpose: to establish the rules under which a government department exercises power over civilians.
Seven questions emerged.
My name appeared in none of them.
Seven Questions. Apparently, Seven Too Many.Andrew Rosindell, my Member of Parliament, tabled the questions on
13 October 2026. They became Written Parliamentary Questions
34520–34526.
In plain English, they asked:
- What rules govern restrictions on civilians?
- Which policies regulate the creation, retention, review, correction and removal of named restrictions, warnings or notifications in Defence visitor-management and access-control systems?
- Who takes responsibility for flagging someone?
- Is a direction to create such an entry a decision, implementation of an earlier decision, or neither? What record must identify its authority, reasons, evidence, duration and review date?
- Can someone be restricted before asking to visit?
- Can a precautionary entry be created before a civilian requests access? When is an individual assessment required, and how frequently must the entry be reviewed?
- Can an investigation into one person justify a restriction on another?
- Can information concerning Service personnel support an adverse entry about an associated civilian who is not the subject of that investigation? Is a separate assessment required?
- What role may origin play?
- Outside national-security vetting, and before an application to visit, may nationality, place of birth or citizenship history contribute to a precautionary restriction?
- What safeguards apply when Service Police pass information to another police force?
- Which data-protection regime applies? How are facts distinguished from assessments, categories of people distinguished and accuracy checked?
- Who searches for records held elsewhere inside the Ministry?
- If one part receives a subject access request but another part holds the data, who coordinates the search? Must the individual apply again? Can an office decline to search merely because it does not own the system?
These questions have consequences far beyond my circumstances.
A warning appears beside your name. An official acts on it. Information travels to another authority. You ask who authorised it, what evidence supported it and how an error can be corrected.
The answers determine whether safeguards exist in practice or merely feature in reassuring public statements.
Then the Ministry Found MeOn
10 November, Starbuck Coleman, who heads Andrew’s office, forwarded the Department’s response.
It had already been published on
21 October, under the name of
Louise Sandher-Jones, Minister for the Armed Forces.
The Department declined to answer all seven questions because one of Andrew’s constituents had ongoing proceedings against it.
That constituent was me.
Romford had 72,928 registered electors at the last general election. Apparently, the Ministry needed only one litigant to explain why seven questions about its procedures should go unanswered. Me. Yes, I know I am special. The questions asked about government procedures. The answer introduced a litigant.
No policies identified. No procedures explained. No attempt to distinguish one question from another.
Apparently, the Ministry could identify the person behind the enquiry more readily than it could explain the rules governing its own conduct.
My name was not in the questions. But apparently, I was the answer.
The Department did not name me publicly. It did, however, expressly make the existence of an identifiable constituent’s litigation the reason for withholding information requested by her MP.
That deserves rather more attention than a shrug and the observation that ministers sometimes refuse to answer questions.
Read question 34520 and the published response.I Know Something About Names in State FilesMy Polish ancestors experienced persecution. Russian and Polish history are part of my understanding of what can happen when a state acquires the power to classify people without adequately answering to them. For this reason I know that 1984 book was a warning, not a manual.
That history makes me attentive to the moment when an institution begins treating the identity of a person as a substitute for addressing the substance of an enquiry.
The question becomes secondary. The file becomes decisive.
A perfectly ordinary request can then arrive at a perfectly polite dead end because the person associated with it has already been placed in a category: complainant, litigant, difficult correspondent.
Historical persecution involved far more than administrative silence. A refusal to answer parliamentary questions does not establish that anything comparable is happening here.
But historical awareness should sharpen our scrutiny of public power. It should not require us to wait for something catastrophic before questioning its smaller evasions.
Here is the circularity that concerns me.
I challenge the Department in court. The Department invokes that challenge as a reason to withhold explanations from Parliament.
How far is that reasoning supposed to travel?
“It Has Happened Before” - Is Where the Analysis BeginsI looked for precedents.
Litigation-related refusals exist. That much is clear. Their existence does not dispose of the question whether this refusal is adequately justified.
In
June 2007, Lord Steel asked what the Government would do following the Court of Appeal’s judgment concerning the Chagossians’ right to return. The relevant proceedings had been brought by
Louis Olivier Bancoult, an individual whose challenge concerned a wider community.
The Government described its consideration of a further appeal and declined additional comment.
The question expressly concerned a particular judgment. The connection to litigation was already on its face.
In
April 2014, Matthew Offord asked five questions about the allocation of legal-aid contracts in 2010, including specific circumstances surrounding an award to Aman Solicitors.
The minister declined the group because of ongoing litigation against the Lord Chancellor. An individual procurement challenge brought by
Hersi & Co Solicitors concerned closely related matters, although I have not conclusively established that the parliamentary refusal referred exclusively to that case.
In
April 2016, Stuart Blair Donaldson asked about sponsorship licences revoked or restricted in connection with allegations of English-language-test fraud.
The Home Office supplied a link to published data before declining further comment because of litigation. The answer did not identify which of the proceedings in that field it meant.
These are three examples found through research, not an exhaustive history of ministerial refusals.
They demonstrate that information can be withheld because of litigation. They do not explain why seven general questions should receive no substantive answer because one of the questioner’s constituents is suing the Department.
I cannot establish that the Ministry’s formulation is historically unique.
I can establish that it chose to make the constituent the explanation.
Chagos, 2007. · Legal-aid contracts, 2014. · Chagos, 2007.How Much Silence Can One Woman Generate?My name appears to have acquired considerable administrative reach.
Complaints handling knows about my proceedings. Legal services certainly knows. Now the parliamentary answering process has invoked them too.
The Ministry’s published instructions identify its
Parliamentary Branch as the point of contact for parliamentary questions. The public record does not show who drafted this particular response, what advice they received or whether a partial answer was considered.
I cannot tell you what anyone feared.
I can identify what the Department left unexplained.
Take question
34526. It asks who coordinates a search when personal data is held in another part of the same Ministry.
Anyone who has been passed between public offices can understand the problem.
Why should describing that general responsibility require a minister to comment on my evidence or prejudge my claims?
The answer does not say.
Nor does it explain why general policy cannot be separated from its application to my circumstances. It simply spreads the same refusal across seven questions covering several different procedures.
That is a very large area of silence to attribute to one constituent.
MoD instructions on contact with parliamentarians. · MoD instructions on contact with parliamentarians.The Standards Exist. Here Is the Letter.I wanted to test the response against the Government’s own published standards and put the resulting argument through the appropriate parliamentary channel.
On
10 November, I sent the following email to
Starbuck Coleman, asking him to put the request to Andrew. I reproduce it in full, including its sources.
Subject: WPQs 34520–34526: request for referral to the Procedure CommitteeHi Starbuck,
Thank you for forwarding the response. Please ask Andrew to refer the grouped answer of 21 October 2026 to Written Parliamentary Questions 34520–34526 to the Procedure Committee for consideration of its adequacy against the published standards for parliamentary answers.
Applicable standardsThe Government's Guide to Parliamentary Work provides:
- Paragraphs 207–208: Members should receive full and timely responses; ministers should make the utmost effort to provide accurate and helpful answers.
- Paragraph 213: answers should address the question asked and should not omit helpful information.
- Paragraph 221: questions should be approached with a predisposition to provide relevant information fully.
- Paragraph 223: non-disclosure should be explained in terms similar to the grounds used under FOIA; an express statutory citation is not required.
- Paragraphs 63–65: the House authorities determine the application of the sub judice resolution, with the Table Office advising and obtaining information from departments.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/guide-to-parliamentary-work/guide-to-parliamentary-work-htmlParagraph 7 of the Cabinet Office's Guidance on drafting answers to parliamentary questions separately requires an explanation where material information is withheld:
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/61195/drafting-pq-responses.pdfGrounds for referralThe seven questions seek general departmental policies and procedures. They do not identify me or ask Parliament to determine my claims. I recognise that some subject matter overlaps with my proceedings. That does not, without further explanation, establish why every question must be refused in its entirety.
The answer makes my status as a litigant constituent the express basis for withholding all the requested information. It does not explain:
- which information could not appropriately be provided, or how providing it would affect the proceedings;
- why general policy could not be distinguished from its application to my circumstances;
- why no question, or separable part of a question, could receive a substantive answer.
For example, question 34526 asks who coordinates a subject access search where relevant data is held by another part of the Department. The answer does not explain why describing that general allocation of responsibility would require comment on a disputed issue in my proceedings.
https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-10-13/34526I do not suggest that acceptance for tabling eliminates all legitimate grounds for withholding information, or that ministers must disclose everything requested. The narrower concern is whether this undifferentiated refusal adequately discharges their parliamentary accountability obligations.
Requested actionThe Procedure Committee's recommendations on answer quality, reproduced in its report containing the Government response, particularly the recommendation identified as paragraph 21, encourage Members to provide examples of allegedly poor-quality answers so that underlying problems and patterns can be examined:
https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm5901/cmselect/cmproced/325/report.htmlPlease ask Andrew to send the seven questions and grouped answer to the Chair of the Procedure Committee, requesting consideration of:
- Whether the explanation satisfies the published standards for withholding information.
- Whether constituent litigation is being used too broadly to prevent scrutiny of general departmental policy.
- Whether further guidance is needed on separating general policy answers from comments on live proceedings.
The referral would concern parliamentary scrutiny, not the merits of my claims or an attempt to obtain a litigation advantage.
Please confirm whether Andrew will make the referral and, if so, provide me with a copy.
Kind regards,
Janina White
A Public Question, Whatever Happens NextI trust Andrew will forward this request. His office helped bring the questions into Parliament, and I welcome that work.
The next step gives Parliament an opportunity to examine the adequacy of the answer it received.
If Andrew decides not to make the referral, for political or any other reasons, I would want to understand those reasons. I do not presume that he will decline, or attribute motives to a decision he has not made.
But the public-interest question should remain available for examination regardless of the route it takes.
That is why I am publishing the letter as an open request for scrutiny. Publication does not itself constitute a formal submission to the Committee. It does put the argument, the evidence and the proposed action into the public domain.
Others who encounter a similar refusal are welcome to adapt it as a template: identify the question, identify the information withheld, test the explanation against the published standards, and ask their MP to pursue the appropriate parliamentary route.
For now, my request has been sent. A referral has not yet been confirmed. If it is made, we will see what the Procedure Committee says.
Seven questions asked the Ministry to explain its procedures.
The Ministry pointed to me.
I am putting the questions back where they belong: before the people responsible for answering them.