When the Comparator Preserves the Protected Ground. What the Northwood access dispute asks of the Equality Act


How a visit to Northwood became a discrimination claim

Janina White is a British and Polish citizen and a solicitor in England and Wales. She was born in Saint Petersburg, but for the last 35 years she lived in Poland and then in the UK. In 2024 - 25 she was in a relationship with Commander Laureano Pastor Veiga, a Spanish naval officer assigned to NATO’s Allied Maritime Command (MARCOM) at Northwood Headquarters.

Northwood is a UK military site. The signed Defence identifies the UK commanding officer as responsible for controlling access. That division of responsibility matters because information about the relationship came from the MARCOM environment, while the decision challenged in the Equality Act claim concerns what UK authorities did with it.

On 12 December 2024, White attended a MARCOM winter event on a red escorted visitor pass. The pass covered that event and gave her no continuing entitlement to enter. In June 2025, according to the Defence, MARCOM told the Northwood security squadron that Pastor was under investigation and that the concerns involved White and potential links to Russia. The commanding officer subsequently learned where she was born. The Defence says that Pastor was told on 20 June that his pass had been suspended. In a letter of 23 June to Rear Admiral Delgado, the commanding officer described Pastor as presenting a security risk because of his current relationship and said the information was not fully verified.

The Ministry admits that Northwood made separate entries in its security visitor management system, SISYS. Pastor needed approval to enter and could no longer escort visitors. His wife, from whom Pastor was separated from summer 2024, and children could be admitted only with approval and under escort. White’s entry said she was not allowed on site and directed staff to contact the Northwood Police and Security Squadron if she attempted entry. On 26 August 2025 she went to Northwood, to assist Pastor with document collection and seek clarification.

She was refused entry and the encounter escalated to involvement by RAF Police and Hertfordshire Constabulary. She received no notification of the personal restriction and only learned of it in October 2025. The MoD disputes that it was required to inform her whilst admitting that Pastor was informed about his restrictions as well as his wife's and children's.

White’s claim against the Secretary of State for Defence is before the County Court at Romford (N00RM961). For direct discrimination, the distinction that matters is between the ordinary conditions for a visitor to enter and a personal instruction preventing her admission, including under escort on her case. Pastor’s loss of his pass explains why he could no longer escort her. The separate entry raises the question of what would happen if another authorised person offered to do so. The arrangements for Pastor and his family help explain the scope of the different measures. Their roles and access status differ from White’s, and their treatment serves a different purpose from the statutory comparison.

What each comparator keeps constant

A comparator is the person whose treatment, actual or hypothetical, helps answer whether the claimant was treated less favourably because of a protected characteristic. Section 13 of the Equality Act 2010 supplies that test. Section 23 requires no material difference between the circumstances relating to each case. Section 9 includes nationality and ethnic or national origins within race. Birthplace is a biographical fact whose relevance here depends on the significance the decision-maker gave it.

White’s Particulars give the example of a British woman born in Manchester, in a materially similar relationship, without independent access or recognised dependant status and without an identified personal conduct-based security concern. The example tests what would happen to a civilian of a different national origin. The question concerns the same personal restriction on escorted entry under the same ordinary access requirements, with any independently material security facts preserved.

At paragraph 37(i), the Defence admits that race was a factor in the decision to refuse White access and says her relationship with Pastor was another necessary factor. Its comparator is also a British civilian born in Russia, in an informal relationship with a MARCOM officer, without independent access. It further requires an investigation in which the civilian’s place of birth was a factor. The MoD says it would treat anyone meeting that description in the same way. The admission concerns the access decision. The Defence continues to deny unlawful discrimination.

When the comparison assumes the answer

The MoD’s strongest point is that an ongoing investigation can be a material operational circumstance. A military site may reasonably take account of reliable information received through an allied investigation. The question is what that information showed about the civilian and why it mattered to escorted access. Preserving the fact of an investigation is one thing. Preserving the significance given to the civilian’s birthplace within it requires a further explanation when that significance is itself disputed. If the comparator already meets both conditions, equal treatment within that group leaves open what difference the use of birthplace made.

James v Eastleigh Borough Council offers a useful analogy. The council offered free swimming to people of statutory pensionable age, which was 60 for women and 65 for men. Defining the comparator group by pensionable status would have carried that sex-based distinction into the comparison. The Court of Appeal rejected that approach and the House of Lords approved the rejection, as the Court of Appeal later explained in Cornerstone. The analogy concerns the structure of the comparison. The link between sex and pensionable age in James was explicit. At Northwood, the evidence must show how the investigation, the relationship and the use of birthplace bore on the particular restriction.

The comparison can be tested even if Pastor would have been investigated in any event.

Suppose his British civilian partner was born in Manchester and was of a different national origin. Keep the ordinary visitor rules, the relationship and any independently relevant security information the same. Would the MoD still have entered an instruction barring her in her own name, even if another authorised person could escort her? If so, what information would have supported that step? Shamoon explains why a court can begin with the reason for the treatment when the choice of comparator obscures the inquiry. Here the admission about race sharpens that inquiry, while the scope of the decision and the role of the other factors remain matters to be assessed.

James v Eastleigh Borough Council [1990] 2 AC 751, 762A–C

What national security has to explain

Section 192 provides a separate defence for acts done to safeguard national security that are proportionate for that purpose. The MoD says the exclusion was a precaution while Pastor’s investigation was pending. It cites access-control and administrative instruments and says that the commanding officer did not know whether, or to what extent, White’s birthplace presented a security risk. Uncertainty can explain why a decision-maker considered a precaution. Proportionality still turns on the risk identified at the time, why ordinary escorted-access controls were insufficient, how widely the instruction operated and when its justification was reconsidered.

White disputes that the restriction served the stated purpose. She alleges that it was used to set administrative action against Pastor in motion. That allegation turns on evidence of the sequence, the information passed between decision-makers and the reasons for their decisions. Neither the terms of the SISYS entry nor the admission about race alone resolves that dispute. The scope, duration and review of the measure matter because they help test the MoD’s account of a temporary precaution.

The question the court still has to answer

The comparator proposed by the MoD treats the attribution of security significance to birthplace as part of the background. If the court accepts that condition as decisive, identical treatment of two people already subject to the same disputed criterion could be used to dispose of the challenge to the criterion itself. The better comparison preserves the independently relevant circumstances and asks whether the same instruction would have been entered against a civilian of a different national origin. That leaves the MoD free to identify any genuinely material security facts and to justify the measure under section 192. It also keeps the focus on the decision White challenges: what the state did to her personally, and why.

Made on
Tilda