I have recently discovered that I have something in common with a Chinese businesswoman named Alice Huang.

At first glance, this is rather unlikely.

Alice operates in the world of international technology, semiconductor supply chains and the increasingly hostile competition between China and the United States.

I am a British solicitor, also a Polish citizen, born in Leningrad when it was still part of the Soviet Union. I have lived in Britain since 2004. My professional interests include law, institutional accountability and the rather complicated relationship between individuals and the organisations that exercise power over them.

Alice has been linked in international reporting to Jensen Huang, the chief executive of Nvidia, a company whose technology has become central to the geopolitical contest over artificial intelligence.

My story concerns a relationship with a Spanish naval commander serving at NATO's Allied Maritime Command in Northwood, England.

Her circumstances involve reported American intelligence allegations, semiconductor exports and possible Chinese intelligence interests.

Mine involve a Christmas party, an authorised visitor pass, rumours circulating within a military community and a British government department that subsequently confirmed it had never determined that I represented a national-security threat.

We are different women, from different backgrounds, involved with different men, in different institutional environments.

The allegations concerning us are not remotely equivalent.

Which is precisely why I find what happened next so interesting.

But first, some facts.

I. TWO WOMEN, TWO VERY DIFFERENT STORIES

The Chinese businesswoman

In November 2026, international reporting brought Alice Huang into the centre of an extraordinary story.

According to journalists citing American intelligence sources, she was suspected of acting on behalf of China's Ministry of State Security. Her reported relationship with Jensen Huang raised questions about possible intelligence access and influence at one of the world's most strategically important technology companies.

There was also a commercial dimension.

Alice had been associated with Singapore-based Megaspeed International, a business operating in a sector increasingly affected by American restrictions on the export of advanced semiconductor technology to China.

These are not trivial circumstances.

Modern economic espionage does not necessarily involve stealing a classified military document. It can concern technology, research, intellectual property, commercial relationships and information whose strategic value is not immediately obvious to the general public.

There are legitimate reasons why American authorities might investigate whether a foreign intelligence service sought access to people involved in strategically sensitive technology.

But the existence of a legitimate investigative question does not establish the answer.
The intelligence underlying the allegations concerning Alice has not been publicly disclosed. Its reliability cannot be independently assessed from the published accounts alone.

A reported intelligence assessment is evidence that an allegation has been made. It is not, without further examination, proof that the allegation is correct.

Nor does the existence of an intimate relationship establish that the relationship was created for an intelligence purpose.

That distinction is particularly important because Alice's story rapidly became something larger than a question about corporate security.

It became an international spectacle.

The British solicitor

My introduction to the world of alleged espionage was considerably less glamorous.

On 12 December 2024, I attended a Christmas social event at Northwood Headquarters, where my then-partner, Commander Laureano Pastor Veiga of the Spanish Navy, was serving at NATO's Allied Maritime Command.

I attended with an authorised, one-day escorted visitor pass.

This is not merely my recollection.

The British Ministry of Defence confirmed the existence of the pass in its Summary Grounds of Resistance, filed in legal proceedings on 13 November 2025.

In June 2025, concerns relating to Commander Pastor's relationship with me became part of decisions affecting access to Northwood.

His access was withdrawn. A restriction concerning my own escorted entry was recorded.

I challenged the decisions and the explanations given for them.

In its court document, the Ministry of Defence made an important admission: neither the Commanding Officer nor any other British decision-maker had determined that I represented a threat to national security.

The department nevertheless defended the restrictions as precautionary security measures.

It also argued that my place of birth was a relevant consideration in assessing access to Northwood. Later, my place of birth was converted to race - in MoD's opinion, my Soviet place of birth makes me racially different from other British women.

I was born in the Soviet Union. That is a historical fact.

Whether, and in what circumstances, that fact can rationally support a contemporary security assessment is a separate legal question.


Then another document emerged.
A Service Police Complaints Commissioner review dated 30 April 2026 recorded that a female RAF Police officer had acknowledged awareness of rumours circulating within MARCOM, including a rumour that I was believed to be a Russian spy.

The officer did not identify the source of the rumour.

The review also found an inaccuracy in an earlier official complaint response concerning the officer's awareness of those rumours.

It did not establish who originated the allegation, whether it influenced any particular access decision, or that the officer had acted with discriminatory bias.

Those limitations are important.

But the document establishes something that would otherwise be very difficult to demonstrate: the allegation existed within the institutional environment.

In the materials I have examined, I have not found an intelligence assessment identifying me as an operative of the Russian state, a description of espionage activity attributed to me, or evidence of information I supposedly obtained or transmitted on Russia's behalf.

So let us compare.

In Alice's case, journalists report that American intelligence agencies possess information supporting an allegation of foreign intelligence activity. The underlying material has not been made public.

In my case, an official review records the existence of a rumour, but the available documents do not establish its evidential foundation.

One story begins with a reported intelligence allegation. The other contains an officially documented institutional rumour converted by the British administrative machine into a real security sanction.

They are not the same.

And intellectual honesty requires us to resist the temptation to pretend otherwise.

II. WHAT WOULD A COUNTER-INTELLIGENCE OFFICER ACTUALLY LOOK FOR?

I am a solicitor, not a counter-intelligence officer.

But legal reasoning and intelligence analysis share an important discipline: both require the analyst to distinguish an observed fact from an inference, and an inference from a conclusion.
The distinction is easily lost when the subject is emotionally compelling.

A foreign-born woman.
A military officer.
An intimate relationship.
A strategically sensitive institution.

The ingredients are familiar. They almost assemble themselves into a spy thriller.

But an interesting story is not an evidential assessment.

Suspicion is not a finding

Security professionals are entitled to investigate vulnerabilities.

Indeed, they would be failing in their responsibilities if they ignored credible risks merely because those risks involved someone's private life.

Romantic relationships can create opportunities for coercion, influence, inadvertent disclosure or deliberate intelligence collection.

Foreign intelligence services have exploited intimacy. The practice is neither imaginary nor exclusively associated with women.

But identifying a possible vulnerability is different from concluding that a particular person is engaged in espionage.

The first is a question about risk.
The second is a proposition about conduct and intent.
The evidential requirements are not identical.

Nor should they be confused.

Consider my visit to Northwood in December 2024.

The contemporaneous authorisation is relevant evidence about the circumstances of entry.

It does not, by itself, answer every conceivable security question. But it prevents the visit from being accurately characterised as unauthorised merely because somebody later became suspicious of the visitor.

Now consider my birthplace.

I was born in Leningrad in 1976. I subsequently, as a teenager, became a Polish citizen and then a British citizen.

A security authority may legitimately consider relevant foreign connections in an appropriate risk assessment.

But birthplace cannot simply be treated as a proxy for present allegiance, still less for participation in a foreign intelligence operation.

The question must be what the information actually establishes about the risk under consideration.

Not what cultural associations it evokes.

What happens when the suspected vulnerability reports a breach?

There is another dimension to the Northwood story.

Commander Pastor reported suspected irregularities involving his NATO UNCLAS laptop and personal electronic communications.

His written report to SHAPE Counter Intelligence, dated 25 July 2025, raised concerns about possible unauthorised access and apparent anomalies involving WhatsApp and email. It was an ultimate escalation, when his attempts to report it directly to his immediate command received no interest or action from that command. The SHAPE was not interested in investigating his concerns either.

I do not claim that those reports establish a cyber intrusion.

A forensic investigation would be needed to determine whether unauthorised access occurred, what systems were involved, who had access and whether information was compromised.
Nor can I establish that intimate material was accessed or viewed by colleagues for amusement.

But the possibility of sensitive personal information becoming entangled in an institutional security dispute raises a separate question.

What happens to privacy when a person's relationship becomes an object of official suspicion?
Who is authorised to inspect personal communications?
What safeguards govern their use?
How is a legitimate security inquiry prevented from becoming an invitation to examine an individual's intimate life?

These are questions of information governance as much as counter-intelligence.

I have explored other aspects of the security chronology, including events at NATO's STRIKFORNATO headquarters in Oeiras, Portugal, in my separate article, The Russian Spy Who Found Two NATO Security Breaches

The present question is broader.

A serious security system must be capable of examining both human vulnerabilities and reported technical irregularities without confusing suspicion with proof.

And it must be capable of recognising when its own assumptions are influencing the interpretation of information.

Espionage is a legal concept, not a personality type

This is where the lawyer in me becomes particularly uncomfortable with the casual vocabulary of spy stories.

Espionage is not simply an accusation that somebody is foreign, romantically involved with a person in a sensitive position, or behaving in a manner that others find suspicious.

In the United Kingdom, the National Security Act 2023 provides a modern statutory framework for espionage-related offences.

Section 1 concerns specified conduct involving protected information, subject to the statutory requirements relating to prejudicial purpose and the relevant foreign-power or designated-body condition.

Other provisions address trade secrets and assisting foreign intelligence services.

The precise elements vary between offences.

Some are concerned with obtaining, copying, recording, retaining or disclosing protected information. Others address different forms of conduct connected to foreign intelligence activity.

Certain offences carry a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.

That is the scale of seriousness with which Parliament treats the subject.

Of course, an administrative security decision is not a criminal prosecution.

An authority responsible for protecting a military installation does not have to wait until somebody has been convicted of espionage before considering precautionary restrictions.
Risk assessment is necessarily prospective.

Criminal adjudication is concerned with proof of defined offences.

But the distinction between those functions does not authorise an institution to substitute stereotypes for evidence.

A security assessment must still identify the relevant risk and evaluate the information rationally.
A person's nationality, origin or intimate relationships may form part of the context.

They do not, without more, establish hostile intent.

A relationship is not an intelligence operation merely because one partner has access to sensitive information.

A security concern is not a finding of espionage.

And a person described as a spy has not thereby committed the crime of spying.

These distinctions ought to be elementary.

Yet the public vocabulary of espionage frequently dispenses with them.

Which brings me back to Alice Huang.

And to the rather strange thing we have in common.

III. THE ONE THING WE HAVE IN COMMON

Alice Huang's story generated reporting about American intelligence, semiconductor technology and Chinese strategic interests.

It also generated another description.

Honeypot.
Honeytrap.

The woman who supposedly enters a relationship with a powerful man in order to extract information, manipulate decisions or compromise him.

In November 2026, WIRED published an article under the headline China's Nvidia Honeypot Isn't Surprising. Jensen Huang Fell for It Anyway.

Notice what happens when an allegation is expressed in those terms.

The existence of a relationship is no longer merely one circumstance to be investigated.

It becomes the organising principle of the story.

The woman's sexuality supplies the presumed mechanism.

Her intimacy becomes evidence of purpose.

And the audience is invited to recognise a character it already knows.

In my case, Spanish press reporting introduced a different expression.

Red Sparrow.

The reference is unmistakable: the fictional Russian intelligence operative whose sexuality is developed into an instrument of espionage.

I cannot establish who first applied that expression to me, or whether it played any role in official decision-making.

But I can identify what the expression does.

It takes a woman born in the Soviet Union, involved in a relationship with a NATO officer, and places her inside an existing cultural narrative.

The story requires remarkably little additional explanation.

Everybody knows what a Red Sparrow is supposed to be.

Two very different allegations. Two very different evidential foundations. One remarkably similar sexualised character.

That is the point at which the subject ceases to be simply espionage.

It becomes a question about how society interprets women.

The extraordinary convenience of a label

Labels are efficient.

They reduce complexity.

They relieve the listener of the burden of examining inconvenient details.

A person becomes a category, and the category supplies its own explanation.

Once a woman has been labelled a honeytrap, almost anything she does can be interpreted through that assumption.

If she is attractive, her appearance becomes a potential instrument of recruitment.
If she is intelligent, her intelligence becomes evidence of sophistication.
If she is affectionate, her affection may be interpreted as manipulation.
If she is professionally successful, her achievements may be treated as useful cover.

Even the absence of obvious suspicious conduct can be explained away as evidence of careful concealment.

This is a familiar problem in reasoning.

An allegation becomes resistant to falsification because every observation is interpreted as consistent with it.

The hypothesis no longer competes with alternative explanations.

It absorbs them.

Lawyers encounter analogous problems when witnesses become committed to an interpretation of events, when institutions repeat earlier descriptions without examining their sources, or when a conclusion is treated as an established premise in subsequent decisions.
In complex institutional environments, information can acquire apparent authority simply by being repeated.

A rumour becomes a concern.

A concern becomes s a recorded characteristic.

And the original evidential foundation may become progressively harder to identify.

That sequence is a possible mechanism, not a finding about what happened in either Alice Huang's case or mine.

But it is precisely the kind of mechanism that administrative justice should be equipped to detect.

Because the authority of a record does not necessarily establish the reliability of the information recorded.

Let us change the sex

Now imagine a British male solicitor, born in the Soviet Union, with Polish and British citizenship.
He becomes romantically involved with a female Spanish naval officer serving at NATO headquarters.

He attends a military social event on an authorised visitor pass.

His birthplace is subsequently identified as relevant to an access decision.

Rumours circulate that he is a Russian spy.

Would his sexuality become central to the story?
Would colleagues immediately reach for a cinematic character associated with sexual manipulation?
Would the public be invited to imagine him as a seducer trained to extract military secrets?

Possibly.

Male intelligence operatives have used intimate relationships, and men can be subjected to sexualised suspicion.

But the experiment invites us to consider whether the same facts would produce the same narrative with equal ease.

Now reverse the Nvidia story.

Imagine a Chinese businessman involved in the international semiconductor trade.
He develops an alleged intimate relationship with the female chief executive of a major American technology corporation.

American intelligence sources reportedly suspect him of working for Beijing.

Would the principal focus be his sexual attractiveness?
Or would journalists examine his commercial connections, financial interests, access to technology and alleged intelligence relationships?

Again, we cannot establish the answer through imagination.

But the exercise exposes the assumptions that shape the questions we ask.

When a man approaches power, do we investigate his interests? When a woman approaches power, are we more readily tempted to investigate her sexuality?

The answer may vary by case, culture and institution.

The question deserves serious examination precisely because the distinction is not always obvious to those making it.

Sexuality as entertainment

There is a broader cultural problem here.

Society has a complicated relationship with sexual behaviour, particularly when it intersects with celebrity, status and power.

The Russell Brand case provides an uncomfortable illustration.

For years, Brand's public persona was associated with sexual excess, provocation and an exaggerated image of masculine desirability.

His reputation formed part of his entertainment identity.

Serious allegations of sexual misconduct were subsequently investigated by journalists and the police, followed by criminal proceedings.

The significance of the case for this discussion is not that allegations against Brand and allegations of espionage are legally comparable. They are not.

Nor should allegations be confused with judicial findings.

The relevance lies in the institutional and cultural question: how can conduct or attitudes treated as entertaining within one social environment acquire a very different meaning when subjected to proper scrutiny?

Channel 4's 2024 internal investigation acknowledged that a serious complaint made by an employee in 2009 had not been properly investigated or escalated, while distinguishing that failure from knowledge of the specific allegations reported in 2023.

An organisation's failure to handle a complaint properly is not proof that everybody within it knew that criminal offences were being committed.

But the episode illustrates why institutional culture deserves examination alongside individual conduct.

The same behaviour can be interpreted differently depending on the status of the person involved, the expectations of the audience and the prevailing assumptions of the institution.
The law attempts, imperfectly but necessarily, to impose a different discipline.

In sexual-offence investigations, prosecutors are required to assess evidence without relying on myths about how victims should behave.

A woman's sexual history, appearance, emotional response or manner of conducting relationships cannot simply be substituted for evidence about the offence under investigation.
That principle has a wider intellectual significance.

The fact that society finds someone's sexual behaviour interesting does not make that behaviour legally probative.

And the fact that a sexualised explanation is culturally familiar does not make it factually correct.

Consider the asymmetry.

A powerful man's sexual reputation may become part of his public appeal.

A woman's sexuality may become the supposed explanation for her hidden intentions.
The man can be treated as entertaining.

The woman is treated as dangerous.

These are not universal rules. They are patterns worth examining, not conclusions to be imposed on every individual case.

But they reveal why the language of honeypots and Red Sparrows deserves more scrutiny than it ordinarily receives.

It is not merely colourful language.

It carries assumptions about agency, manipulation, credibility and power.

What does the label actually prove?

Let us examine the proposition with the discipline of a lawyer.

Suppose someone calls a woman a Red Sparrow.

What facts have been established?

That she has received training from a foreign intelligence service?
No.

That she has obtained protected information?
No.

That she has transmitted information to a foreign power?
No.

That she entered a relationship for an intelligence purpose?
Not without independent evidence.

The expression establishes none of those things.

It establishes only that somebody has chosen to describe her through a particular stereotype.

The same applies to honeypot.

It may describe a genuine intelligence technique where the underlying facts support that conclusion.

But when applied to an individual before the relevant conduct and purpose have been established, it can operate as an allegation disguised as a description.

That distinction is not semantic pedantry.

It is the difference between identifying evidence and assigning a character.

The danger becomes greater when the label is sexualised.

Sexuality is intensely personal, socially charged and capable of provoking strong emotional reactions.

It can invite fascination, contempt, envy, moral judgment or ridicule.

Those reactions may have nothing to do with the legal or security question.

Yet they can influence how readily an audience accepts an allegation.

The more entertaining the story, the less inclined people may be to ask whether it has been proved.

What if the audience is an institution?

This is where the subject becomes particularly serious.

A joke made in a private conversation may be offensive or unfair, but it does not necessarily exercise public power.

An institution is different.

A military organisation, police force, regulator or government department can make decisions that affect an individual's rights, access, reputation and opportunities.

It can maintain records.

It can transmit information to other bodies.

It can make judgments that the affected person may not immediately know about, understand or be able to challenge.

And it may operate within systems where the original source of an allegation is difficult to identify.

In my case, administrative restrictions were imposed.

The MoD's court documents acknowledge their existence.

An official police complaints review records awareness of rumours that I was believed to be a Russian spy.

The documents do not establish that the rumours caused the restrictions. The documents also establish that nothing has been done to identify and contain those rumours.

That is a question requiring evidence, not rhetorical certainty.

But the coexistence of a sexualised narrative, a documented espionage rumour and actual administrative consequences raises an important issue about institutional safeguards.

How does an organisation ensure that an unverified characterisation does not become a factual premise?
How does it distinguish intelligence from gossip?
How does it prevent irrelevant information about someone's intimate life from contaminating a security assessment?
And how does an individual correct a perception whose source remains unidentified?

There is a profound procedural difficulty here.

An ordinary factual allegation can often be answered.

A visitor can produce an entry permit.

A person can establish citizenship through official documents.

A particular communication can be examined through metadata, access logs or witness evidence.

But how does a woman prove that she is not the fictional character somebody has imagined her to be?
What evidence would disprove an accusation that has never been properly articulated?
And what remedy is available when the allegation is never formally made, yet may still influence how she is perceived?

This is one reason why the accuracy of institutional records matters.

It is also why procedural fairness cannot be reduced to the formal legality of the final decision.
The information used to reach that decision, the assumptions made about it and the opportunities available to correct errors are all part of the accountability problem.

An administrative system can be procedurally elaborate and still fail to identify a flawed premise.

The woman disappears; the character remains

Perhaps the most disturbing feature of sexualised labels is how efficiently they erase the person concerned.

The woman has a name, a profession, a history, relationships, convictions, ambitions and a private life.

The label replaces all of that.

She becomes the Russian spy.

The Chinese honeytrap.

The dangerous foreign woman.

The audience no longer needs to know her.

It already knows the character.

It can speculate about her sexuality without understanding her relationships.

It can attribute motives without examining her conduct.

It can laugh at the story without considering what it may do to her reputation.

And if the label becomes embedded in an institutional environment, the consequences may extend far beyond embarrassment.

I cannot establish that private or intimate information from my former partner's laptop was accessed or used for entertainment. That remains a question, not a finding.

But even without such access, a sexualised nickname can turn an individual's intimate life into a subject of collective speculation.

That is revealing.

Not necessarily about the woman.

About the people doing the speculating.

A label can function as a form of social permission.

Permission to reduce a person to her sexuality.
Permission to treat her relationship as suspicious.
Permission to regard her private life as a source of amusement.
Permission, sometimes, to stop asking what she has actually done.

And this is where the historical figure of Mata Hari remains relevant.

More than a century after her execution for espionage in 1917, her name survives as a cultural shorthand for the seductive female spy.

The historical controversies surrounding her case are complex. The mythology is much simpler.
That simplicity is precisely the point.

The archetype has outlived the evidence, the politics and the legal proceedings that produced it.

It is available whenever society wants a ready-made explanation for a woman whose intimacy intersects with power.

The geopolitical adversary changes.

The technology changes.

The institutions change.

But the character remains recognisable.

IV. WHAT THE LABEL REVEALS

I began with two women who have almost nothing in common.

Alice Huang is the subject of serious allegations reported in the context of American intelligence and strategically sensitive technology.

I am a British solicitor whose relationship with a NATO officer became entangled in security decisions based on unverified rumours of Russian espionage.

I do not know whether the allegations concerning Alice will ultimately be substantiated.

I do know that the official documents concerning me record the existence of rumours without establishing that I engaged in espionage.

Our stories differ in almost every material respect.

Yet both were given the language of sexualised intelligence.

Honeypot.
Red Sparrow.

There is a temptation to dismiss such expressions as colourful shorthand.

I think that would be a mistake.

Language is not always innocent.

It can shape what people notice, what they overlook and what they believe requires no further explanation.

A sexualised label can make a complex allegation feel immediately plausible because the audience already recognises the character.

And when that happens, the woman may be required to answer not for her conduct but for the story that others have constructed around her.

This does not mean that women cannot be intelligence operatives.

They can.

It does not mean that intimate relationships are irrelevant to security.

They may be highly relevant.

Nor does it mean that every use of the word honeypot is misogynistic or factually incorrect.

The question is whether we have become so comfortable with a particular image of female espionage that we sometimes mistake the image for evidence.

That is a serious question for journalists.

It is a serious question for intelligence professionals.

And it is a particularly serious question for institutions that exercise authority over individuals.
Because a sexualised rumour may begin as entertainment.

It may remain entertainment.

But if it influences the recording, interpretation or circulation of information within a public authority, it may become something else entirely.

It may become part of the machinery through which decisions are made.

The person affected may never discover who created the label, who repeated it, who believed it or whether it influenced the decision that changed her life.

And the institution may find it easier to defend its formal procedure than to examine the assumptions on which that procedure relied.

That is not merely a feminist concern.

It is a question about the quality of institutional reasoning and the limits of state power.

Espionage is a serious legal matter. A woman's sexuality is not evidence of espionage.

The distinction ought to be obvious.

Yet two remarkably different stories suggest that it is worth stating again.

Perhaps the most revealing question is not why Alice Huang was described as a honeypot, or why the expression Red Sparrow appeared in reporting about me.

Perhaps it is why these descriptions are so immediately intelligible, so easily repeated and so entertaining to the people who encounter them.

What does it say about a society that can transform a woman's intimate relationship into a spy story before the evidence has been properly examined?

And what does it say about our institutions if they cannot always demonstrate where the story ends and the evidence begins?

When we call a woman a Red Sparrow or a honeytrap, what have we actually established about her?

And what does it reveal about people who call her that?.
Made on
Tilda